Split Decision
Split Decision
Indecisive? Maybe. Iconic? Always. This cookie doesn’t want to choose—and why should it? One half is rich chocolate caramel, the other is salty peanut butter, both packed with depth, comfort, and chaos. Inside is a gooey center with pb and caramel that oozes when you heat it up. “Split Decision” is a love letter to every Gemini who changes their mind mid-sentence, orders two drinks because they can’t pick one, and somehow still wins you over with a smile. This is the ultimate “I want both” cookie—and honestly, you deserve both.
(For the Gemini who can’t pick a favorite song, outfit, or person… and never has to.)
Care Instructions: At Madison Square Bakery we individually wrap and heat seal our cookies to maintain peak freshness. These babies are best eaten immediately. For that perfect crispy outside and gooey center, heat cookies in a 350˚ oven (outside of their packaging) for 3-5 minutes or until warm. Extras should be stored in original packing inside an air tight container for up to 3 months in the freezer. When ready to eat, thaw and reheat them in the oven.
CONTAINS: NUTS!
*Disclaimer* Cookies are made with equipment and in a kitchen that also houses wheat, dairy, soy, nuts, coconut, and shellfish. If you are highly allergic to any of those things, please do not risk your health! This is NOT a vegan kitchen but we do try our best to not cross-contaminate!